Choosing a dog toy subscription box sounds simple—until your dog destroys every toy within minutes or loses interest just as fast. Chewing is a natural and healthy behavior for dogs, but not all dogs chew the same way. Some dogs gently nibble plush toys, while others aggressively tear, shred, and break anything they get their paws on.
That difference matters when choosing between two popular subscription boxes: Bullymake and BarkBox.
Both brands are well-known, trusted, and loved by dog parents. However, they are designed with different chewing behaviors and play styles in mind. This comparison breaks down how each box works, what type of dog it’s best for, and how to decide which option fits your dog—without hype, exaggeration, or one-size-fits-all claims.
If your dog destroys toys quickly or gets bored easily, this guide will help you make a confident decision before subscribing.
Jump To Key Sections
Table of Contents
- Quick Comparison Snapshot
- What Is Bullymake?
- What Is BarkBox?
- Toy Materials and Chewing Experience
- Customization and Fit for Your Dog
- Choosing Based on Your Dog’s Behavior
- Safety, Supervision, and Expectations
- Pricing and Subscription Basics
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Final Thoughts: Which Should You Choose?
Quick Comparison Snapshot
| Feature | Bullymake | BarkBox |
|---|---|---|
| Designed for | Power chewers | Moderate chewers |
| Toy materials | Nylon, rubber | Plush, rubber mix |
| Toy themes | Yes | Yes |
| Customization | Yes | Yes |
| Subscription type | Monthly | Monthly |
| Best suited for | Dogs that chew intensely | Dogs that enjoy variety |
This table offers a quick overview, but the real decision depends on how your dog plays and chews, which we’ll explore in detail below.
What Is Bullymake?
Bullymake was created specifically for dogs that tend to destroy standard toys quickly. The brand focuses on toy durability and material strength, offering toys made primarily from nylon and hard rubber. These materials are commonly preferred by dog owners dealing with aggressive or heavy chewers.
Each Bullymake box is subscription-based and delivered monthly. During signup, dog parents can customize their box based on:
- Dog size
- Toy material preference
- Treat inclusion or toy-only options
Bullymake also incorporates fun themes and designs, keeping the experience engaging while maintaining a focus on longer-lasting play.
Who Bullymake is usually a good fit for:
- Dogs that chew intensely
- Dogs that break plush toys quickly
- Owners prioritizing durability over variety
- Dogs that enjoy firm chew textures
You can explore current Bullymake options to see how their boxes are customized for different chewing styles.
What Is BarkBox?
BarkBox is one of the most well-known dog subscription boxes and is designed for a wide range of dogs, especially those who enjoy variety, themed play, and plush toys. Each monthly box typically includes a mix of toys, treats, and chews, all centered around a playful theme.
BarkBox allows customization based on:
- Dog size
- Allergies
- Treat preferences
- Play style
The brand focuses heavily on the experience—from creative toy designs to seasonal themes—making it popular among dogs who enjoy novelty and softer toys.
Who BarkBox is usually a good fit for:
- Moderate chewers
- Dogs that enjoy plush toys
- Dogs that get bored with repetitive toys
- Owners who enjoy themed, surprise boxes
You can view BarkBox plans to see how their themes and customization work.
Toy Materials and Chewing Experience
One of the biggest differences between Bullymake and BarkBox is toy material, which directly affects durability, safety, and enjoyment.
Bullymake Toy Materials
- Primarily nylon and rubber
- Designed for firm chewing
- Often preferred by dogs that focus on chewing rather than fetching or tug
BarkBox Toy Materials
- Plush toys combined with rubber or mixed materials
- Designed for interactive play and variety
- Often better suited for dogs that enjoy squeaking, shaking, and light chewing
No toy is indestructible, and supervision is always recommended. However, matching the toy material to your dog’s chewing style helps reduce frustration and toy waste.
Customization and Fit for Your Dog
Both services allow customization, but they approach it differently.
Bullymake customization focuses on:
- Toy strength preferences
- Dog size
- Option to receive only toys
BarkBox customization focuses on:
- Dog size
- Treat preferences and allergies
- Toy style variety
If your dog has specific dietary needs, BarkBox’s treat customization may be appealing. If your primary concern is toy longevity, Bullymake’s material-based customization may be more relevant.
Choosing Based on Your Dog’s Behavior
This section is the most important part of the decision.
Choose Bullymake If:
- Your dog destroys toys quickly
- Your dog prefers firm chewing over plush play
- Durability matters more than toy variety
- You want toy-focused boxes with material control
Check Bullymake availability to see current box options.
Choose BarkBox If:
- Your dog enjoys plush toys
- Your dog likes variety and themed play
- You want a mix of toys and treats
- Your dog is a moderate chewer
View BarkBox plans to explore current themes and customization.
Safety, Supervision, and Expectations
Regardless of the subscription you choose:
- No toy lasts forever
- Supervision is important during play
- Toys should be inspected regularly
- Chewing style, play habits, and supervision all affect toy lifespan
Toy durability depends on the individual dog, not just the brand.
Pricing and Subscription Basics
Both Bullymake and BarkBox operate on a subscription model with monthly delivery. Pricing can vary depending on:
- Subscription length
- Customization options
- Box type
Subscription pricing reflects toy materials, customization, and shipping frequency rather than a single product purchase.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which box is better for dogs that chew aggressively?
Dogs that chew intensely often do better with firmer toy materials, which may make Bullymake a better fit for some households.
Are toy subscription boxes safe for puppies?
Toy choice should always be age-appropriate. Puppies benefit from supervision and softer materials during teething stages.
Can I customize boxes for my dog’s size?
Yes, both services offer size-based customization.
What if my dog loses interest in toys?
Rotating toys and choosing boxes with variety can help maintain engagement.
Final Thoughts: Which Should You Choose?
There is no universal “best” toy box—only the best match for your dog’s chewing behavior and play style.
If your dog consistently destroys toys and prefers firm chewing, Bullymake may align better with your needs. If your dog enjoys plush toys, surprise themes, and variety, BarkBox may be a better fit.
When in doubt, choosing the box that matches your dog’s natural chewing habits is usually the safest decision.
Explore Your Options
Affiliate disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you choose to subscribe through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
